Browning toast and searing meat

Section 2 of 4

Toast, a seared steak, roast potatoes and the crust of a loaf all turn brown and taste richer through one reaction between sugars and amino acids: the Maillard reaction (say my-YAR).

Bread, meat and potatoes all hold the molecules of life: proteins, free amino acids with their amine group, -⁠NH₂, and a little sugar, such as glucose. At any moment a tiny share of glucose molecules open out of their ring, and an open glucose molecule ends in an aldehyde group, C=O.

In the heat, the C=O group of a sugar meets the -⁠NH₂ group of an amino acid. The two join and give off a water molecule: a condensation, like the ones that make esters. The joined molecule then rearranges, breaks into pieces and joins up again, over and over.

The Maillard reaction between a sugar and an amino acid Top: a sugar, drawn as a six-sided ring with one red oxygen atom, plus an amino acid, drawn as a blue circle marked N for its amine group. An arrow labelled heat points down to the two joined together, with a water molecule, H2O, given off. A second arrow points down to many new molecules: small rings and a chain, some with an oxygen or nitrogen atom, labelled flavour molecules, and a long brown zigzag chain labelled brown colours. + N a sugar an amino acid heat N H₂O they join and give off water flavour molecules brown colours
The Maillard reaction. A sugar and an amino acid join and give off water, then the joined molecule breaks up and rejoins into hundreds of flavour molecules and brown colours.

The French chemist Louis-⁠Camille Maillard described the reaction in 1912. Food chemists have since found hundreds of products. The brown ones are big molecules called melanoidins. The small ones carry the smells of baking and roasting, and each amino acid gives its own mix, so toast, roast chicken, coffee and chocolate each smell different.

2-Acetyl-1-pyrroline, C₆H₉NOThe roasty smell of bread crust. A five-membered ring of four carbon atoms and one nitrogen atom, with a C=N double bond, carrying an acetyl group, -COCH₃, on the carbon of the C=N.ON
2-⁠Acetyl-⁠1-⁠pyrroline, C₆H₉NO: the roasty, cracker-like smell of bread crust. Its ring nitrogen comes from an amino acid, and it carries a ketone group.

Hot and dry

The Maillard reaction runs slowly at room temperature and fast from about 140 °C. Water boils at 100 °C, and while a food's surface is wet, the heat goes into turning that water to steam, so the surface stays at about 100 °C. In a hot pan, an oven or a toaster, the surface dries out, climbs past 140 °C and browns.

How cooking heat decides the colour
CookingHeat, aboutSurface
boiling or steaming100 °Cstays pale
frying in a pan150 to 200 °Cbrowns
roasting or baking180 to 220 °Cbrowns

So boiled meat stays grey, and cooks pat a steak dry before it goes in the pan. A cut apple turns brown by another reaction, which lesson 17 explains: an enzyme in the apple uses oxygen from the air to join the apple's phenols, small molecules with -⁠OH groups on benzene rings, into brown pigments. That browning happens at room temperature.

Quick check

Meat simmered in a stew stays grey, and the same meat seared in a hot, dry pan turns brown. Why?