Swapping one letter

Section 3 of 4

For years, mRNA made in the lab had a problem: cells treated it as an invader. The answer was a small change to one of its four letters.

Many viruses carry their instructions as RNA, so your cells keep watch for RNA from outside. Sensor proteins such as TLR7 and TLR8, two of the Toll-like receptors, fit single strands of RNA, especially strands rich in U. A switched-on sensor sets off an alarm: the cell sends out messengers that bring on inflammation, and other sensors slow the cell's own protein building. Early mRNA made in the lab set these alarms off, and cells made little protein from it.

At the University of Pennsylvania, the biochemist Katalin Karikó and the immunologist Drew Weissman noticed that RNA from our own cells set off the alarms far less. Our own RNA carries some of its letters in modified forms. In 2005 they showed that mRNA built with modified letters, among them pseudouridine in place of uridine, hardly set off the sensors. In 2008 they found that cells made much more protein from mRNA carrying pseudouridine.

A ring turned round

Uridine, the U in RNA, is uracil joined to ribose. A nitrogen atom of the uracil ring holds the sugar, through a carbon-nitrogen bond. In pseudouridine, the same ring is turned round and joined to the sugar through one of its carbon atoms: a carbon-carbon bond. The nitrogen atom that held the sugar now carries a hydrogen atom.

N1-methylpseudouridine carries a methyl group, -⁠CH₃, on that nitrogen in place of the hydrogen, and later work found that it keeps the alarms quieter still, while cells make even more protein. Every U in the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna mRNA is N1-methylpseudouridine.

Uridine as a skeletal formula A six-membered ring of four carbon atoms and two nitrogen atoms, uracil, with C=O groups at the top and at the lower right and an N-H group on the right. Its bottom corner is a nitrogen atom, joined by an amber carbon-nitrogen bond to a five-membered ribose ring below, of four carbon atoms and one oxygen atom, with two -OH groups and a CH2OH group. NNHOOOOHHOHO
Uridine, C₉H₁₂N₂O₆: a nitrogen atom of the uracil ring holds the ribose ring, through a C–⁠N bond (amber).
N1-methylpseudouridine as a skeletal formula A six-membered ring of four carbon atoms and two nitrogen atoms, with C=O groups at the top and at the lower right and an N-H group on the right. Its bottom corner is a carbon atom, joined by an amber carbon-carbon bond to a five-membered ribose ring below, of four carbon atoms and one oxygen atom, with two -OH groups and a CH2OH group. The nitrogen at the upper left of the six-membered ring carries an amber methyl group. NHNOOOOHHOHO
N1-methylpseudouridine, C₁₀H₁₄N₂O₆: the ring is turned round and a carbon atom holds the sugar, through a C–⁠C bond (amber). The methyl group (amber) sits on the nitrogen that held the sugar in uridine.

Read as a U

Look at the right-hand edge of both rings: a C=O, an N–⁠H and another C=O, in the same places. That is the edge that pairs with A, through hydrogen bonds, as T pairs with A in DNA. So the ribosome reads the new letter as a U, and nearly every spike protein comes out the same.

Quick check

What joins the ring of N1-methylpseudouridine to its ribose sugar?

Saved

Sort saved items

Starred items stay on top in either order.

Save a figure, a table or a section with its bookmark button, and it appears here.