Sparks in a flask

Section 1 of 5

Every living thing is built from carbon compounds. Before there was life, where did the first ones come from? In 1952 a student set out to make some from scratch, with gases, water and sparks.

Stanley Miller was a graduate student at the University of Chicago, working with the chemist Harold Urey. Urey thought the young Earth's air was rich in hydrogen and its compounds, the gases that fill the air of Jupiter today. Miller sealed three of them, methane, CH₄, ammonia, NH₃, and hydrogen, H₂, into a 5-litre glass flask, joined it by glass tubes to a small flask of water, and boiled the water. Water vapour from the boiling flask ran round the loop, and two metal electrodes sent sparks through the gases, day and night, like lightning in a storm.

Miller's spark experiment A small round flask of water, bottom left, is heated by a flame. Steam rises from it up a glass tube and along the top into a big round flask, top right, labelled gases: methane, ammonia and hydrogen. Two electrodes come into the big flask from the left and the right, and an amber spark jumps between their tips. A tube leads down from the bottom of the big flask through a condenser, where the gases are cooled, and back along the bottom to the small flask. The liquid that runs down it is labelled amino acids collect. steam sparks CH₄, NH₃, H₂ gases cooled amino acids collect boiling water
Miller's apparatus. The small flask of boiling water stood for the sea, the big flask for the air and the sparks for lightning. A condenser cooled the gases, and the liquid ran back to the small flask, carrying whatever the sparks had made.

A reaction needs energy to get over its energy hill, and breaking the strong C–⁠H and N–⁠H bonds in methane and ammonia takes a lot of it. The sparks gave that energy. Bonds broke, and the atoms joined up again with new partners. Within a day the water had turned pink, and after a week it was deep red and cloudy.

Miller separated the mixture by paper chromatography and sprayed the paper with ninhydrin, which turns amino acids purple. Purple spots showed up: glycine and alanine, two of the amino acids that build proteins, and a few others. He published the result in May 1953. Simple gases, water and energy had made the building blocks of proteins, with no living thing involved.

A second look

Miller kept dried samples from his experiments in small sealed vials. After he died in 2007, his former student Jeffrey Bada and his team tested some of them with modern instruments, far more sensitive than paper chromatography. In 2008 they reported more than 20 amino acids in the samples from one 1950s run, in which Miller had blown steam through the sparks, as at an erupting volcano.

The early air

Today most geologists think the young Earth's air was mainly carbon dioxide and nitrogen, with water vapour and only a little methane, ammonia or hydrogen. Sparks in that mixture make far fewer amino acids. In 2008 a team that included two of Miller's former students found that chalk, which keeps the water from turning acidic, and iron, which protects the amino acids from the nitrite and nitrate the sparks make, raise the amount a great deal. Volcanoes give out hydrogen and other gases, so the air round an eruption, often lit by lightning, may have been much like Miller's flask.

The gases in Miller's flask, and what geologists now think the young Earth's air held

GasMiller's flaskEarly air
methane, CH₄yesa little
ammonia, NH₃yesa little
hydrogen, H₂yesa little
water vapour, H₂Oyesyes
carbon dioxide, CO₂nonea lot
nitrogen, N₂nonea lot

Quick check

What did the sparks do in Miller's experiment?

Saved

Sort saved items

Starred items stay on top in either order.

Save a figure, a table or a section with its bookmark button, and it appears here.