Vents and warm ponds

Section 4 of 5

Where on the young Earth did this chemistry turn into life? Two places lead the search: hot springs on the deep sea floor, and warm pools on land. Both are hypotheses, ideas that chemists and geologists are still testing.

Earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago, soon after the Sun. Some of the oldest widely accepted signs of life, layered mounds built by microbes and kept in the rocks of Western Australia, are about 3.5 billion years old. The first living things arose somewhere in between.

Two places where life may have begun Two pictures side by side. Left, a deep-sea vent: a rocky chimney rises from the sea floor, and amber arrows and small bubbles rise from its top, labelled warm, alkaline water with H₂. Right, a warm pond on land, drawn twice. In the top picture, labelled wet, the pool holds water with a few separate amber building blocks in it. In the bottom picture, labelled dry, the water has gone and five building blocks sit joined in a chain. Arrows run down from wet to dry and back up again, labelled again and again. The sun shines above. warm, alkaline water with H₂ chimney sea deep-sea vent wet dry again and again warm pond on land
Two places where life may have begun. At a deep-sea vent, warm water rich in hydrogen rises through a rocky chimney. In a pond on land, building blocks join into chains each time the pool dries out.

Deep-sea vents

In 1977 the submarine Alvin found hot springs on the sea floor near the Galápagos Islands, with clams and giant tube worms living round them in the dark. In 2000 scientists found a different kind in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean, the Lost City. Its pale chimneys of carbonate rock stand up to 60 metres tall, and the water flowing out of them is warm, 40 to 90 °C, and alkaline, about pH 9 to 11. Seawater reacting with the rock deep below gives it hydrogen gas, H₂.

The vent idea says that at chimneys like these, hydrogen and carbon dioxide reacted on minerals of iron, nickel and sulfur, making the first carbon compounds. The early sea, rich in carbon dioxide, was probably more acidic, so the thin chimney walls would have had alkaline water on one side and acidic water on the other. Hydrogen ions would have flowed across them, much as hydrogen ions flowing through ATP synthase power your own cells.

Warm ponds on land

The pond idea puts the start in hot springs and pools on volcanic land. Pools fill with rain and dry out again, over and over. Each time a pool dries, its building blocks crowd together in a thin film. Joining two building blocks into a chain gives off water, a condensation like the one that joins amino acids, and drying takes that water away, so the joins form. In the lab, mixtures of RNA building blocks taken through many wet and dry rounds have joined into short chains like RNA.

Each idea explains some steps well and leaves others open. At a vent, water all round can pull new chains apart. On land, the young Earth's pools faced strong ultraviolet light from the Sun. Experiments in the years ahead may tell the two ideas apart, or show that the chemistry of life used more than one place.

Quick check

Why might a pool that dries out help building blocks join into chains?

Saved

Sort saved items

Starred items stay on top in either order.

Save a figure, a table or a section with its bookmark button, and it appears here.